What’s the best defence to an interim order application?

It depends on the circumstances, of course, but yesterday in front an HCPC panel, I persuaded the panel, not that an order was unnecessary in the circumstances, but that the panel had no jurisdiction to make an order at all!

This is the first time that I have run this particular argument, and it occurred in a very specific context. As it was, I had several arguments to run as to why an order was not necessary, attacking various strands of the HCPC case - but they were all rendered moot by what was ultimately a simple argument; the HCPC had no power to apply for an interim order.

Even before the client had instructed me, on a brief review of their papers, it struck me that perhaps this was a case where the legal basis for making the application could be challenged. My experience of personally running cases across several regulators and representing personally my clients in hearings at those various regulators, meant that something set me thinking immediately about processes elsewhere, and wondering what was the legal position at the HCPC.

I did some immediate research and what was an inkling became a rapidly solidifying legal argument.

All parties, the HCPC barrister, the panel’s legal adviser and the panel chair were somewhat surprised by the point I took - but as I explained my client’s position it became clear to all that my reasoning was correct.

I’ve been doing this work for 12 years now, 60-70 clients a year, but the firsts still keep on coming!

Next
Next

GOC fitness to practise hearing - no impairment outcome!